Table 1: Characteristics of studies included in meta-analysis.

First author (year) Sample N mean age (± sd) Sex Sport Groups Concussion measurement
Baillargeon, et al. (2012) [5] N = 96
9-12 = 11 (± 1.2)
13-16 = 14.8 (± 1.1)
Adults = 23.3 (± 3.3)
Male S, H, F, R Control = 48
Concussed = 48
American Academy of Neurology
Maugans, et al. (2012) [21] N = 24
13.41 (sd not reported)
Male, Female S, F, W Control = 12
Concussed = 12
Guidelines developed at the 3rd conference on sport concussions
McCrea, et al. (2010) [22] N = 56
(age not reported)
Male F Control = 28
Concussed = 28
American Academy of Neurology
Covassin, et al. (2010) [18] N = 188
Males = 18.35 (± 2.77)
Females = 18.29 (± 2.24)
Male, Female BB, SB, F, L, VB, B, S, G, R, W Control = 50
Concussed = 138
Immediate Post-Concussion Assessment and Cognitive Testing
Colvin, et al. (2009) [33] N = 234
Male = 16.3 (± 2.4)
Female = 16.5 (± 2.4)
Male, Female S Control = 101
Concussed = 133
American Academy of Neurology
Shuttleworth-Edwards, et al. (2008) [24] N = 45
Concussed = 19.85 (± 1.46)
Control = 23.39 (± 3.87)
Male R, CT, SW Control = 18
Concussed = 27
Not Reported
Fazio, et al. (2007) [20] N = 192
Concussed = 16.7 (sd not reported)
Control = 17.3 (sd not reported)
Male, Female F, S, B, W, SW, TR, O Control = 70
Concussed = 122
American Academy of Neurology
Ellemberg, et al. (2007) [19] N = 22
22.7 (sd not reported)
Female S Control = 12
Concussed = 10
American Academy of Neurology

Note: F: Football; VB: Volleyball; L: Lacrosse; BB: Baseball; B: Basketball; S: Soccer; W: Wrestling; FH: Field Hockey; H: Hockey; SB: Softball; R: Rugby; C: Crew; G: Gymnastics; CT: Cricket; SW: Swimming; TR: Track; O: Other.