Table 8: Advantages and disadvantages of oven-dry method and halogen moisture analyzer method.
Instrument |
Advantages |
Disadvantages |
Drying oven |
A drying oven can estimate several samples' moisture content at the same time • It can determine the water content of large sample volumes • It has a simple procedure to perform |
The drying time is very long (hours) • It can evaporate other soil's substances other than water • Additional equipment needed, such as precise measuring scale, and sample containers • The drying oven method requires handling and calculation; therefore, it is prone to error • Not portable • Occupies relatively a large space in the Lab |
Halogen moisture analyzer |
• Quick measurement • Portable • The halogen moisture analyzer does not require any calculation, and its sampling is simple; therefore, the possibility of errors decreases. • The heating rate is fast; therefore, the halogen moisture analyzer can quickly reach its maximum power • The equipment is fully automated • Needs a very small space
|
• It can evaporate other soil's substances other than water • The maximum amount of soil the moisture analyzer is limited to the specimen holder size |