Table 4: Summary of our literature review of comparable studies.
Reference |
Study population Mean age Follow-up |
Treatment |
Results |
Complications |
[9]
|
22 patients 75 years (61-90) 42 months (12- 91) |
12 patients: Revisions with long stem 8 patients: Proximal humeral implant changed with implantation of an intramedullary implant that bridged the fracture 2 patients: Prosthetic cap with initial stem left in place |
- Time to union: 27 weeks
- Scores worse than after primary surgery |
2 revisions for dislocation and 1 for intraprosthetic dislocation 1 nonunion 1 revision for fixation failure 1 infection 2 nerve-related complications |
[10] |
9 patients 70 years (45-85) 47 months (4-196) |
5 conservative treatment 2 surgical fixations with screws and wire cerclage 2 stem revision |
-Union in 8 patients in 4-6 months -3 satisfied -6 not satisfied because of loss of motion |
2 radial neuropraxia |
[8]
|
16 patients 63 years (37-76) 67 months (4-191) |
6 conservative treatment 5 delayed surgical treatment (123 days after conservative treatment failed) 5 immediate surgical fixation |
-Time to union 6 months after conservative treatment -Time to union 278 days after surgical treatment -9/16 patients dissatisfied because of loss of motion |
1 infection |
[7] |
21 patients, of which 16 fractures were intraoperative 60 years (40-80) 27 months (12- 72) |
5 conservative treatment 8 long stem and wire cerclage 8 standard stems +/- internal fixation |
Union: - 3.5 months for conservative treatment - 2.5 months for long stems - 8.7 months for standard stems |
43% complication rate 4 neurapraxia 1 capsulitis 1 infection |
[10] |
6 patients 72 years (67-94) 43 months (13-85) |
1 conservative treatment 1 surgical fixation 4 long stems |
- 100% union - 100% patients satisfied - Complete recovery of range of motion |
2 residual pain (medium intensity) |