Table 1: Key features of main references of original papers and case reports (excluding reviews, meta-analyses or commentaries).
Author, ref. and date |
Solid organ year of transplant |
Age (y) Sex (m/f) |
IST |
Symptoms at presentation |
Temp SpO2 CRP CT chest |
Severity Stage (Siddiqi) |
Treatment |
Outcome |
Li F, et al. [47] |
Heart, 2003
|
51, m
|
Tac MMF |
intermittent fever chills fatigue poor appetite diarrhea |
38.5 99%--> 75% 18.6 mg/L GGO (bilat.) |
IIA --> IIB |
levofloxacin iv ribavirin iv
moxifloxacin iv ganciclovir iv
IVIG methylprednisolone iv
moxifloxacin po umifenovir
Tac and MMF stopped from day 7-13
|
survived, hospitalization 27 days, no mechanical ventilation or ECMO, CT at discharge improved (residual lesions).
|
Li F, et al. [47] |
Heart, 2017 |
43, m |
Tac MMF |
fever (2 days) fatigue poor appetite |
38.5 normal SpO2? 13.4 mg/L GGO (bilat.) |
IIA |
ceftriaxone iv ganciclovir iv moxifloxacin po arbidol po |
survived, hospitalization 11 days, no mechanical ventilation or ECMO |
Kates O, et al. [48] |
Heart, 1997 |
74, m
|
Tac Mes |
sore throat dry cough |
40, SpO2 and CRP unknown
CXR normal |
I |
immunosuppression unchanged |
survived no hospitalization |
Hsu JJ, et al. [15] |
Heart and Kidney, 2017 |
39, m |
Tac MMF Pred |
fever headache sore throat dry cough dyspnea fatigue myalgias |
38.8 97% 67 mg/L CXR mild congestion |
I --> IIB |
Tac unchaged MMF stopped Pred continued |
survived, hospitalization 15 days |
Zhu L, et al. [49]
|
Kidney, 2008 |
52, m |
Tac MMF Pred |
fatigue dyspnea chest pain tightness nausea loss of appetite abdominal pain dry cough fever headache |
38.9 96% 30.2 mg/L GGO (bilat.)
|
IIA |
umifenovir methylprednisolone interferon-a inh. IVIG biapenem pantoprazole
Tac stopped from day 6-11, reintroduced with 50% reduction for 7 days, followed by normal doses
MMF stopped from day 6-11, reintroduced by normal dose after 12 days
pred stopped during hospitalization |
survived, hospitalization 12 days, no mechanical ventilation or ECMO |
Guillen E, et al. [50] |
Kidney, 2016 |
50, m |
Tac Everol Pred |
fever vomiting |
37.4 98% 13.2 ml/L unilateral --> bilat. infiltrate |
IIA--> IIB
|
ceftriaxone azithromycin lopinavir/ritonavir HCQ
TAC and everol temporary stopped due to interactions
interferon-b
intubation and MV |
|
Gandolfini I, et al. [51] |
Kidney, 2010 |
75, m |
Tac Pred MMF |
Fever Cough Myalgia Dyspnea |
38.0 SpO2 and CRP unknown GGO |
IIB |
NIV HCQ Lopinavir-ritonavir or darunavir-cobicistat |
died |
Gandolfini I, et al. [51] |
Kidney, 2019 |
52, f |
Tac Pred MMF |
Fever Cough Myalgia Dyspnea |
39.0 SpO2 and CRP unknown GGO |
IIB |
NIV HCQ Lopinavir-ritonavir or darunavir-cobicistat Colchicine |
alive |
Bartiromo M, et al. [28] |
Kidney, 1993 |
36, f |
Tac Pred |
Fatigue Dry cough Coryza |
36.3 SpO2 99% CRP 67 CXR infiltrates |
IIA |
lopinavir/ritonavir, later replaced by darunavir/cobicistat
Tac unchanged, but developed extremely high level, stopped after discharge |
survived after 9 days hospitalization |
Marx D, et al. [52] |
Kidney, 2017 |
58, m |
Bela MMF Pred |
Fever Mild dyspnea Cough |
38 SpO2 96%
GGO
|
IIA |
Bela stop MMF stop
|
survived after 16 days hospitalization |
Husain SA, et al. [53] |
Kidney Case Series n = 15 |
51 (21-78), 5 f, 10 m |
Tac MMF Bela Leflu Aza Pred |
Fever Cough Fatigue Malaise Dyspnea Diarrhea Myalgia Hemoptysis Emesis |
CXR bilateral opacities (n = 7, 47%), no acute findings (n = 5, 33%), lobar infiltrate (n = 2, 14%) |
|
Antimetabolites or leflunomide stop (n = 10, 71%)
Tac unchanged
Pred unchanged (n=14, 71%))
Replaced Tac and MMF with pred (n=1, 7%) |
Died (n = 1, 7%)
Intubation (n=4, 27%) |
ZhuL, et al. [54] |
Kidney Case Series n = 10 |
45 (24-65), 2 f, 8 m |
CNI, MM, pred |
|
GGO and/or consolidation |
|
Different regimes, patients on CNI, MMF, pred |
Died (n=1, 10%) |
Fontana F, et al. [12] |
Kidney, 2005 |
61, m |
CyA MTP |
Fever
|
38 SpO2 97% CRP 41 GGO bilat. |
IIA--> IIB |
CyA 50% reduced HCQ MTP increased Tocilizumab IVIG Meropenem |
Survived, hospitalization 22 days |
Kates O, et al. [48] |
Kidney, 2000 |
54, m |
Tac MMF |
Fatigue Dry cough Dyspnea Nausea Vomiting Diarrhea |
38 SpO2 93% CRP unknown CXR multifocal infiltrates |
IIB |
MMF discontinued Tac reduced Pred 10 mg started Ceftriaxon Azithromycin HCQ |
survived, hospitalization 16 days |
Arpali E, et al. [55] |
Kidney 2020 |
28, f |
Tac MMF Pred |
Fever
|
38 SpO2 unknown CRP 4.5 CXR normal |
I |
immunosuppression unchanged |
survived, hospitalization 1 day |
Zhong Z, et al. [56] |
Kidney,
|
48, m |
Tac MMF |
cough muscle aches fatigue chest tightness |
37.8
31 mg/L
GGO |
IIA |
Tac unchanged MMF discontinued
oseltamivir abidol moxifloxacin rh-IFNa MMP IVIG
|
survived, hospitalization 34 days |
Qin J et al. [57] |
Liver, 2020 |
37, m |
Tac Pred |
unknown |
Temp, SpO2 and CRP unknown
GGO |
IIB |
Tac and Pred maintained, gradually titrated to lower doses
HFOT
Oseltamivir rh-GCSF IVIG |
survived, hospitalization 2 months (including liver transplantation) |
Lagana SM, et al. [58] |
Liver, 2020 |
0.5, f |
|
Fever Dyspnea Diarrhea |
"fever"
CXR bilat. infiltrates |
IIA |
CPAP HCQ Pred tapering MMF stopped |
alive |
Huang JF, et al. [59] |
Liver, 2017 |
59, m |
Tac MMF |
Fever Cough Chills Fatigue Diarrhea |
40.0 SpO2 normal CRP 35.1 GGO |
IIA-->IIB --> III |
pip/taz lopinavir/ritonavir alpha-IFN (nebul.)
Tac & MMF reduced (50%) (possible drug-drug interactions with lopinavir/ritonavir)
cefperazone-sulbactam and caspofungin |
day 4: IIB, nasal oxygenation, standard methylprednisolone
day 9: invasive ventilation
day 12: PTx + PE, drainage
day 15: ECMO
Kidney failure
day 45: died |
Kates O, et al. [48] |
Liver 2001 |
67, m |
CyA |
Fatigue Confusion Dry cough Diarrhea |
Temp, SpO2 and CRP unknown
CXR normal |
IIB |
CyA continued |
survived, hospitalization 12 days |
Zhong Z, et al. [56] |
Liver
|
37, m |
Tac MTP |
unknown |
38.6 93% CRP unknown
GGO
|
IIA |
Tac discontinued MTP |
survived hospitalization duration unknown |
Steinack C, et al. [9] |
Lung, 2019 (bilat.) |
55, f |
Tac MMF Pred |
Nausea Vomiting Diarrhea Dry cough Rhinorrhea |
38.9 96% 77 mg/L 3 nodular lesions |
IIA |
piperacillin/tazobactam
|
survived hospitalization 12 days
|
Aigner C, et al. [60] |
Lung (bilat.) 2019 |
59, f |
Tac Pred |
Asymptomatic |
Afebrile Hypoxemia (pO2 55 mmHg)
GGO |
IIB |
Meropenem
Tac and Pred unchanged |
survived
hospitalized 21 days
|
Shigemura N, et al. [61] |
Lung (bilat.) 2020 |
Elderly, m
|
Tac Pred |
Fever
|
38.1 90%
GGO |
IIB --> III |
Tac and Pred continued MMF withheld immediately
remdesivir |
intubation
died, 11 days posttransplant |
Shigemura N, et al. [61] |
Lung (unilat.) 2020 |
Elderly, m |
Information pending |
Severe abdominal pain, watery stool
|
Afebrile GGO in native lung, no GGO in donor lung |
IIB |
remdesivir |
clinically stable, with nasal cannula with 3LO2/min. (follow-up awaited) |
Kates O, et al. [48] |
Lung (bilat) 2000 |
53, f |
CyA Aza Pred
|
Fatigue Dry cough Dyspnea |
Temp, SpO2 and CRP unknown
|
I |
none, immunosuppressive therapy continued |
survived no hospitalization |
Abbreviations: ATG = antithymocyte globulin (thymoglobulin); Aza = azathioprine; bela = belatacept; bilat. = bilateral; CRP = C-reactive protein; CT chest = computed tomography of the chest; CXR = chest X-ray; CyA = cyclosporin A; ECMO = extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; everol = everolimus; GGO = ground-glass opacity; HFOT = high flow oxygen therapy; HCQ = hydroxochloroquine; inh. = inhalation; IST = immunosuppressive therapy; iv = intravenous; IVIG = intravenous immunoglobulin G; leflu = leflunomide; Mes = mesalamine; MMF = mycophenolate mofetil; MTP = methylprednisolone; MV = mechanical ventilation; NIV = non-invasive ventilation; po = per os; Pred = Prednisone; Ptx = pneumothorax; PE = pleural effusion; rh-IFN a = recombinant human interferon alpha; rh-GCSF = recombinant human granulocyte colony-stimulating factor; Tac = tacrolimus, unilat. = unilateral