Table 7: HBDS and other meta-heuristics and swarm intelligence algorithms for FI1-FI7 integer programming problems.
Function | GA | PSO | FF | CS | GWO | HBDS | |
FI1 | Avg SD |
1640.23 425.18 |
20,000 0.00 |
1617.13 114.77 |
11,880.15 623.41 |
860.45 43.66 |
656.56 88.65 |
FI2 | Avg SD |
1140.15 345.25 |
17,540.17 1054.56 |
834.15 146.85 |
7176.23 637.75 |
880.25 61.58 |
344.22 43.32 |
FI3 | Avg SD |
4120.25 650.21 |
20,000 0.00 |
1225.17 128.39 |
6400.25 819.94 |
4940.56 246.89 |
1137.56 85.61 |
FI4 | Avg SD |
1020.35 452.56 |
16,240.36 1484.96 |
476.16 31.29 |
4920.35 247.19 |
2840.45 152.35 |
260.8 10.39 |
FI5 | Avg SD |
1140.75 245.78 |
13,120.45 1711.83 |
1315.53 113.01 |
7540.38 440.82 |
1620.65 111.66 |
1177.12 111.6 |
FI6 | Avg SD |
1040.45 115.48 |
1340.14 265.21 |
345.71 35.52 |
4875.35 865.11 |
3660.25 431.25 |
149.08 8.21 |
FI7 | Avg SD |
1060.75 154.89 |
1220.46 177.19 |
675.48 36.36 |
3660.45 383.23 |
1120.15 167.54 |
222.91 11.19 |