Table 3:
Wilcoxon test for comparison results in Table 2.
Compared methods
Solution evaluations
Method 1
Method 2
R
-
R
+
ρ-value
Best method
HFPGA
VNS-123
0
55
0.005062
HFPGA
HFPGA
VNS-3
0
55
0.005062
HFPGA
HFPGA
GA
0
15
0.043114
HFPGA