Table 4: Performance comparison between electrostatic power (ESP) generator and PV cell.

 

PV Cells

ESP

Notes

Device Concept

Boeing’s spectro Lab Multi-juntion

NASA LaRC’s ESP Module

 

Energy Source

Solar

Negatively charged Regolith

 

Unit Area

10 cm × 30 cm

10 cm  × 30 cm

 

Incident Energy

40 Watts

14.7 watts*

*both Lunar day and night operation

Efficiency

40%

90%

*Efficiency of circuit is much higher (> 90%)

Collected Power

16 Watts

5.88 watts

 

Operation under

Lunar day only

Lunar day and night

 

Energy Storage for kick-off power

No

Yes, for kick-off start

 

Dust Mitigation

No

Yes

 

Fabrication

Complex CMOS skill required

Fairly easy

In-house Fab