Table 4: Performance comparison between electrostatic power (ESP) generator and PV cell.
|
PV Cells |
ESP |
Notes |
Device Concept |
Boeing’s spectro Lab Multi-juntion |
NASA LaRC’s ESP Module |
|
Energy Source |
Solar |
Negatively charged Regolith |
|
Unit Area |
10 cm × 30 cm |
10 cm × 30 cm |
|
Incident Energy |
40 Watts |
14.7 watts* |
*both Lunar day and night operation |
Efficiency |
40% |
90% |
*Efficiency of circuit is much higher (> 90%) |
Collected Power |
16 Watts |
5.88 watts |
|
Operation under |
Lunar day only |
Lunar day and night |
|
Energy Storage for kick-off power |
No |
Yes, for kick-off start |
|
Dust Mitigation |
No |
Yes |
|
Fabrication |
Complex CMOS skill required |
Fairly easy |
In-house Fab |